1
Introduction
2
Communications
3
Traditional Family Values
4
Health Care Beliefs and Practices
5
Health Risks and Concerns
6
Women's Health
7
Youth Health
8
Spiritual Practices
9
References and Resources
1
Introduction
Asians are culturally an extremely diverse group and differently defined in different countries. In New Zealand the term implies an ethnic group and is used to refer to persons with origins across the Asian continent from China in the North, to Indonesia in the South, and from Japan in the East to Afghanistan in the West. It does not include Middle Eastern peoples or people from Russia (Lim & Mortensen, 2014).
Tips
Questions
Asians are culturally an extremely diverse group and differently defined in different countries. In New Zealand the term implies an ethnic group and is used to refer to persons with origins across the Asian continent from China in the North, to Indonesia in the South, and from Japan in the East to Afghanistan in the West. It does not include Middle Eastern peoples or people from Russia (Lim & Mortensen, 2014).
The Asian population constitutes about 10.7% of the New Zealand population. About two thirds of the NZ Asian population reside within Auckland region representing the second largest group there at 20.9%. The largest ethnic populations in the Auckland region are Chinese (38.1%), Indians (34.3%), Koreans (7.1%), Filipino (6.6), and Sri Lankan and Japanese (each 2.2%).
The individual countries that the ethnic group we call ‘Asians’ originate from, have extreme differences in their cultures. Customs can also vary greatly even within a country and there is a danger amongst Anglo Europeans to assume that all people with Asian physical features belong to a homogenous group. Ethnicity (as defined by Ministry of Health, 2001) is more a psycho-cultural identity rather than a genetic one and involves a shared sense of common origins, distinctive history and identity, and a sense of unique collective solidarity. Therefore, seeing ‘Asians’ as an ethnic group can be problematic and sometimes has little meaning to the people themselves.
NB The information in this section is generalized and is intended to highlight some of the differences between the Asian and Western practices and norms. Please refer to sections on specific cultures for more details on each, and for issues particularly pertinent to health care.
2
Communications
Sue to add
Many Asian gestures and greetings differ significantly from Western ones. Below are some essentials for greetings and communication to develop good rapport and show respect. When in doubt, a smile and a slight bow of the head will always be appreciated.
In general for all the Asian cultures in this resource:
- address clients using a title and surname (premature familiarity is considered disrespectful)
- a nod or slight bow is customary
- older people should be greeted first and last before leaving
- avoid prolonged or direct eye contact
- over-familiar touch is not appreciated
- it is acceptable to shake hands with men
- preferably use customary greeting with women
- using hand gestures to summon someone is considered insulting
- in most Asian cultures it is disrespectful to touch another’s head (except for medical examination)
- many Asians will avoid saying ‘no’ as it is considered impolite, so ‘yes’ may be ambiguous and may indicate that the listener is paying attention; it does not necessarily indicate agreement.
- Showing respect, especially for elders, is appreciated (e.g. greeting the elders first, the practitioner being on time for appointment, greeting them in their traditional way)
- Showing an interest in the culture and practices will likely enhance relationship with the practitioner, and compliance
- Health practitioners are usually highly regarded and clients may not ask questions, and may not answer in the negative as it is considered disrespectful. It would be helpful to invite the client and their family to ask questions
- In most Asian cultures ‘Saving Face’ is a strong principle and will be used over confrontation or questioning of those in authority. It is also important not to put a person in a position where they will be seen to ‘lose face’.
3
Traditional Family Values
Sue to add
Asian | Western |
---|---|
|
|
4
Health Care Beliefs and Practices
Sue to add
In general, health care providers should be aware that traditional practices and beliefs of most Asian migrants and refugees are dynamic and that they change considerably after resettlement. In some cases, there may be little or no reliance on traditional practices. In others, illness will result in a reverting back to more traditional practices, especially as it becomes apparent that Western medicine does not have all the answers. Younger people will often seek more modern medical treatment, but may also follow practices passed on to them by their families at the same time. There may be many 2nd and 3rd generation Asians living in New Zealand who do not hold any traditional health beliefs and practices. It is vital to make assessments on an individual basis.
In general Asians tend to be ‘holistic’ in their view of health where ‘Life Force’ balance or ‘Body Balance’, spiritual and supernatural factors, as well as physical / environmental, social, economic, mental, and hereditary factors are seen to be interrelated and interdependent in influencing health. People from rural areas may follow more traditional lifestyles and health treatments than people from urban areas (due to lack of knowledge about modern medicine). Economic status and education (which can vary greatly among people from the same country) are also significant factors. Cultural variations may also be marked between generations. Each of the cultural sections that follow, details the health beliefs and practices specific to that culture.
Some needs and beliefs around Illness and Health
Sue to add
Some needs and beliefs around Illness and Health |
---|
|
Traditional treatments/practices
Sue to add
Traditional treatments/practices Many of the Asian cultures presented in this resource use some or all of the practices below. Please refer to specific cultures for applicability. |
|
---|---|
Coining or Scraping (also referred to as ‘dermabrasion’) |
A popular treatment around 3,000 years ago in rural areas of China (still used today) where the use of an instrument such as ceramic spoons, coins, bone, etc. is used to scrape the skin. The instrument is vigorously rubbed across the skin in a prescribed manner, causing a mild dermabrasion. This practice is believed to release the excess force or "wind" from the body and hence restore balance. It is believed to re-activate the body’s healing mechanism to clear any blockages from dead blood cells and debris from accident areas, and to allow proper circulation. It is used for physical discomforts such as headaches, back pain, joint pain, muscle aches, and a variety of ailments including fever, upper respiratory infection, nausea, weak heart, and malaise. (It may leave marks on the body, not to be assumed a result of physical abuse) |
Cupping |
A series of small, heated ‘cups’ are placed on the skin, forming a vacuum that draws on the underlying soft-tissue. Different cultures have slight variations in the technique, e.g. Laotians fix a piece of cotton in the bottom of the glass, light the string and place the open mouth of the glass on the client’s back. Cambodians may use a small candle on the forehead, in a similar way. The flame consumes the oxygen and creates a vacuum, thus causing a circular contusion. The process can be repeated a number of times in one session and used to treat backache, sprains, and soft-tissue injuries. It can leave a red circular mark. |
Moxibustion |
A soft combustible material (a herb or artemesia vulgaris) is heated and burned indirectly at specified spots on the skin (acupuncture points or energy channels). (This may also leave marks on the body) |
Pinching |
Similar to coining and cupping, by pinching and pulling up the skin, the unwanted ‘force’ is allowed to leave the body (may also leave marks) |
Steaming |
A mixture of medicinal herbs is boiled, the steam is inhaled, and the body bathed |
Balming |
Various medicated oils or balms are rubbed over the skin |
Acupuncture |
Specialized practitioners insert thin steel needles into specific locations known as vital-energy points. Each of these points has specific therapeutic effects on the corresponding organs or functions of the body |
Acupressure or Massage
|
Fingers (or a blunt tool) are pressed at the same points as with acupuncture, and together with massage, stimulate these points to maximize their therapeutic effects. It is used to relieve a variety of symptoms and pain |
Natural Medicine and Herbs (including patented Chinese Medicines) |
Various medicinal potions are ingested or applied topically. These may be consumed for example, in the postpartum, to restore balance. Some are brought to countries of resettlement, or occasionally, found there) by individuals. Others are bought pre-packaged and imported from Thailand or other Southeast Asian countries. Some substances may be classified as "Chinese medicine" such as those medicines/substances sold in Chinese pharmacies worldwide. |
Magico-religious articles |
Amulets, strings, and Buddha images are common. The amulets (which look like a piece of string), may be worn around the neck by children or around the waist by adults. Permission to remove these articles for medical interventions needs to be gained from clients beforehand |
Qi Qong (Chi Kung) |
The name means to cultivate energy or to do energy work. It is an integration of physical postures, breathing techniques and mental focus all of which are aimed at easing or increasing the flow of chi, or directing chi to specific systems or organs within the body. It is sometimes classified as a marital art, and can have medical and spiritual effects. |
Ayurvedic Medicine |
Restores and maintains the balance of the 3 elements in the body (aspects of the Life Force) referred to as doshas: pitta, vatta, and kapha. The rhythms of the pulse as well as clinical history and observation are used in diagnosis. Herbs, oils, dietary management, detoxification, and some massage regimes are included in treatment. This medicine system is traditional in India and there are a number of practitioners in New Zealand (including Westerners who are being locally trained). |
Practices and Beliefs relevant for managing those who are unwell, disabled or dying
5
Health Risks and Concerns
Sue to add
According to Metha’s (2012) report on health needs for Asian people living in the Auckland region, the following were noted as of concern across the different groups studied [1]:
- Diabetes prevalence
- Low cervical screening coverage
- Cataract extractions
- Terminations of pregnancy
- Cardiovascular disease (CVD), coronary heart disease, stroke, congestive heart failure
- High potentially avoidable hospitalisation (PAH) rates
- Utilisation of chronic care management (Care Plus)
- Family violence
- Hysterectomies
- Total knee joint replacements (TKJR)
[1] The Metha 2012 report refers to three ethnic groups stratified in the Auckland region:
Chinese, Indian, ‘Other Asian’ (includes Southeast Asian). Ethnicities include Korean, Afghani, Sri Lankan, Sinhalese, Bangladeshi, Nepalese, Pakistani, Tibetan, Eurasian, Filipino, Cambodian, Vietnamese, Burmese, Indonesian, Laotian, Malay, Thai, Other Asians and Southeast Asians not elsewhere classified (NEC) or further defined (NFD)
Unless otherwise specified, the term ‘Asian’ used in this CALD resource refers to Asians in general and does not imply a specific ethnicity or stratified group.
6
Women's Health
Sue to add
- Adult diabetes during pregnancy is of concern (Metha, 2012)
- Pregnancy is a highly valued and expected stage in a woman’s life
- A good mental state during pregnancy is considered important as the state will be transferred to the baby and affect its future health and wellbeing
- There are a number of taboos during pregnancy to ensure a healthy baby (these include foods and activities)
- There are also specific taboos after delivery to ensure that the mother has no future health problems, g. no showering or washing hair for up to 30 days, need to keep mother and the baby warm
- Post-partum practices are very different to Westerners with new mothers taking plenty of rest in the first month, traditionally staying in bed for 1 week up to 100 days (where possible) and keeping themselves and the baby warm
- Traditional Birth Attendants are available in some Asian cultures and play the role of midwife and will often deliver the baby
- Food plays an important part of healthcare during pregnancy and post-partum period
7
Youth Health
Newborn & Child Health
Sue to add
- Child oral health and child asthma is of concern for some Asian groups studied (See cultural sections for culture specific data)
- In some Asian populations breastfeeding is lacking due to:
- the belief that bottle-feeding is modern and superior
- misinformation about breastfeeding and infant feeding practices
- concerns about privacy and modesty
- communication difficulties with health professionals
- lack of family support
- newborns tend to be kept warm at all times, even in summer
- babies are kept close to stop excessive crying, and may share a room with parents until at least a year old
- children are usually highly valued and seen as an asset to the family, so childhood illness causes immediate anxiety
Adolescent Health
Sue to add
- There is limited or little sexual education amongst some of the Asian groups studied
- Low levels of physical activity are reported for adolescent Asian New Zealanders, especially amongst females
- Mental health is of concern with high levels of depression, especially amongst female students
- Many of the young Asians residing in New Zealand are students with families abroad. Difficulties they commonly face include:
- loneliness
- homesickness
- communication
- prejudice from others
- financial difficulties
- academic performance pressures from family back home
- cultural shock
- Others face:
- status challenges in the family with role-reversals
- family conflict over values as the younger ones acculturate
- health risks due to changes in diet and lifestyle
- engaging in ‘risky’ behaviour (i.e. unsafe sex, binge drinking, smoking, marijuana and other substance abuse) as they become more acculturated
8
Spiritual Practices
Sue to add
For most Asian cultures, religion plays a central role in life and provides a framework for understanding all aspects of living, including illness and health. It is important to acknowledge this role with clients and to have some understanding of the implications of the belief systems.
For some cultures the beliefs and practices are a composite of a number of traditions. Such diversity in spiritual beliefs requires that assessment precede implementation of any type of spiritual care during illness. The most common faiths are tabled below
Outline of religious and spiritual systems | ||
---|---|---|
Faith | Description | Country |
Confucianism |
Confucianism originated in China in the 6th century BC as the major religion or philosophical system. Teachings emphasize devotion and obedience to parents, family and ancestors, honesty, righteousness and benevolence. Also central to Confucianism is ethicality, loyalty to the state and the maintenance of justice and peace. There are 6 different schools. Implications: given the authoritative and hierarchical structures, compliance may be affected by the head-of-the-family’s acceptance of diagnosis and treatment plans |
China Korea Vietnam |
Taoism |
Taoism originated in China in the 6th century BC as a philosophical/religious system based on the doctrines of Lao-tse. Taoism advocates harmony, simplicity, and selflessness. The Tao (Life Force or path) is seen as the first-cause of the universe and the goal of the individual is to harmonize with this force. The concept of Yin-Yang has origins in this system. Implications: the Life Force (Tao) will be restored to balance (and thereby the illness resolved) if the relative principles are employed/adhered to. Western medicine can be seen to interfere with this system |
China Korea Vietnam |
Buddhism
|
Buddhism was also founded in the 6th century BC, and has become a transcultural religious and philosophical system based on the teachings of Gautama Siddhartha, the Buddha. There are a number of branches of Buddhism – namely Theravada (practiced in Burma, Cambodia and also Vietnam), Mahayana which embraces the various traditions within China, Korea, and Japan, and Vajrayana, which is associated primarily with Tibet. Common to all forms of Buddhism is the belief that life involves suffering, that desire and attachment create the suffering, and that this can cease if specific principles are followed. These principles describe ethical, humanitarian and disciplined practices. Central to Buddhist world view is the concept of Karma (the total sum of good and bad deeds over lifetimes) which holds that all actions have consequences and these are seen to influence current circumstances. Implications: ill health may be attributed by many Buddhists to Karma. Some may passively accept this as their fate and seek little treatment, others may actively seek to address the illness by praying, performing rituals or meditating in an attempt to alleviate the problem. The belief that life involves suffering might also cause some practitioners to delay or avoid seeking treatment. |
China Korea India Cambodia Vietnam Laos Burma |
Shamanism /animism |
Shamanism is the belief in positive and negative entities/spirits which affect humans. A Shaman i.e. religious/spiritual practitioner, can traverse at will, between the worlds of the spirits and consensus-reality and influence the entities and the effects they have on humans. It is believed that the Shaman can not only avert bad luck, but also be instrumental in resolving tensions and conflicts between the living and the dead. Integral to this belief is that all aspects of nature have spirit, (referred to as animism). The influence of ancestors is also central to this practice. The correct burial rituals following the death of a relative are thought to ensure a good fortune for the family. Some Asians may maintain shrines or alters in their homes where they are able to honour their ancestors in the traditional ways. Maintaining a good relationship with the environment and its inhabitants is believed to be advisable. Implications: the belief that external forces are responsible for ill health and that appeasing the forces either through their own actions, or with the help of a shaman, will resolve the problem. Some practitioners may use this method before seeking medical intervention. |
China Korea Cambodia (animism) Laos (Phram- animism) Burma (Nat- animism) Vietnam |
Christianity |
Christianity was introduced into the Asian countries presented in this resource at different times, and has varying degrees of influence over those cultures and their spiritual practices. Today many Asians practice Christianity, and with some of the other noted faiths influencing their world views. |
China, Korea India, Vietnam (Catholicism) Cambodia (Evangelist and Mormon) Burma (Catholic, Baptist, Protestant) |
Hinduism is practiced by the majority of people in India. The basis of Hinduism is the belief in the unity of everything (the totality is called Brahman), and the goal is freedom from endless reincarnation (samsara), with karma as central to the cycle. The caste system is another principle concept of Hinduism and divides society into four social classes. The highest class is called the priest class, or the Brahmans. The lowest class is referred to as the laborer class, or Sudras. One inherits class at birth, based on one's karma, or tally of good and bad deeds from previous lives. Implications: for some Hindus there is a fateful attitude to health based on beliefs about karma, and treatment may be delayed or avoided. Others will accept that whilst the illness has karmic origins, treatment can be sought to resolve the problem. |
India |
|
Islam |
Islam is practiced by a small percentage of Asians in the different countries covered in this manual with the highest numbers in India. The cornerstone of Islamic faith, the ‘Five Pillars’ are the obligations which are required of every Muslim. They are: shahadah (statement of faith), salat (prayers), zakat (alms), sawm (fasting), and hajj (pilgrimage). The prophet and teacher within Islam is Muhammed and the holy book, the Qur’an lays out all the religious lore. Muslims believe that paradise is available to all who believe in God, ‘Allah’ and who do good. Unlike Buddhists and Hindus they believe that this world is their one and only chance to earn the gift of paradise. Practicing Muslims with ill health may be challenged to meet the obligations of the 5 daily prayers and fasting and may need assistance to meet these. Implications: that ill health may be God’s will. Some Muslims will passively accept this whilst others will seek treatment. |
India (and small numbers in other Asian countries) |
Sikhism |
Sikhism is a 500 year old religion and practiced by 20 million Sikhs living in India. Guru Granth Sahib is the holy book. The religion combines the Hindu concept of karma (righteous deeds) with the Muslim concept of monotheism and stresses loving devotion to God, universal principles of morality, truth and honest living, and full equality of mankind irrespective of race, caste, creed or sex. Many devout Sikh men wear the kirpan (a traditional small sword) which has sacred religious symbolism of power and freedom of spirit, and is a reminder to Sikhs to fight injustice and oppression, but is not to be used as an instrument of violence. The kirpan is one of five highly emotive articles of faith (the 5 K’s) all of which need sensitive handling when they are affected by medical treatments and care. The 5 K’s are: kes (unshorn hair, as a sign of a saint), kangha (a small comb to keep the hair tidy), kachhehara (knee-length underpants symbolic of propriety), kara (literally a link, a steel bangle worn on the right wrist, as a reminder of the bond between a Sikh and the Guru, and for the need for restraint) and the kirpan. Hospitals and clinics may need to provide guidelines to ensure that Sikh clients are allowed to wear the kirpan without compromising health and safety standards, and ensure that the healthcare staff are informed so that the issue can be sensitively and appropriately dealt with. Implications: although the belief in God’s Will or Karma may play a part in perspectives on health, most Sikhs will readily seek treatment, whether it be allopathic or an alternative. Some may use prayer and practice to find strength during ill health. |
India |
9
References and Resources
View references and resources in the Comprehensive Guide section.
- Asian Public Health Project Report (NZ) February, 2003. Available at: http://www.moh.govt.nz
- Cline, A. Muslim Beliefs. Retrieved July 2006. Available at: http://atheism.about.com/od/islammuslims/p/Beliefs.htm
- Imai, G. Body Language and Nonverbal Communication. Retrieved July 2006. Available at: http://www.xmarks.com/s/site/www.csupomona.edu/~tassi/gestures.htm
- Kemp, C. Korean. Downloaded June/July 2006 from: Http://www3.baylor.edu/~Charles_Kemp/Korean.htm Link no longer currently at February 2015.
- Lim, S. (2004). Cultural Perspectives in Asian Patient Care (handout). Asian Support services. Waitemata District Health Board.
- Lim, S. (2005). Cultural Perspectives in Asian Patient Care (handout). Asian Support services. Waitemata District Health Board.
- Lim, S., Tsang,B. (2005). Asian Children’s Health. Retrieved July 2006. Available at: http://www.asianhealthservices.co.nz
- Lim, S., Mortensen, A. (2014). Best Practice Principles: CALD Cultural Competency Standards and Framework. Waitemata District Health Board. Auckland.
- Mehta S. Health needs assessment of Asian people living in the Auckland region. Auckland: Northern DHB Support Agency, 2012.
- No author. Major World Religions. Retrieved July 2006. Available at: http://www.omsakthi.org/religions.html
- Ministry of Health (2003). Asian Public Health Report.
- Rasanathan, K. et al (2006). A health profile of Asian New Zealanders who attend secondary school: findings from Youth2000. Auckland: The University of Auckland. Available at: http://www.youth2000.ac.nz, http://www.health.govt.nz/our-work/populations/asian-and-migrant-health, http://www.arphs.govt.nz
- No author. Korean Overseas Information Service. Shamanism. Retrieved August 2006. Available at: http://www.koreanculture.org.
- Walker R. (2014). Auckland Region DHBs Asian & MELAA: 2013 Census Demographic and Health Profile. Auckland: Northern Regional Alliance (NRA).